Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison
Mexico, being a Federation, has different levels of jurisdictions, courts and tribunals; many differences exist between courts of different states and between state and federal courts. This chapter will focus in particular on the analysis of the performance models that regulate two of Mexico’s feder...
Guardado en:
| Autores principales: | , , |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Capítulo de libro |
| Lenguaje: | inglés |
| Publicado: |
2023
|
| Materias: | |
| Acceso en línea: | Enlace permanente (DOI o Handle) |
| Etiquetas: |
Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!
|
| _version_ | 1881508960985415680 |
|---|---|
| author | Béjar, Luis José Casanovas, Juan Antonio Vasquez Villanueva, Carlos Alberto |
| author_browse | Béjar, Luis José Casanovas, Juan Antonio Vasquez Villanueva, Carlos Alberto |
| author_facet | Béjar, Luis José Casanovas, Juan Antonio Vasquez Villanueva, Carlos Alberto |
| author_sort | Béjar, Luis José |
| collection | Producción científica |
| description | Mexico, being a Federation, has different levels of jurisdictions, courts and tribunals; many differences exist between courts of different states and between state and federal courts. This chapter will focus in particular on the analysis of the performance models that regulate two of Mexico’s federal judicial bodies: on the one hand, the Judicial Power of the Federation, responsible for ordinary federal justice, but also playing a role as constitutional judge through the amparo trial; on the other hand, the Federal Tribunal of Administrative Justice, endowed with constitutional autonomy, and responsible for administrative litigation and for disciplinary sanctions against state employees. Both federal judicial bodies have in place a career system for civil servants and judges that also takes into account performance-based evaluation. Yet, the contents and effects of such evaluations are notably different in the two bodies. This is why the chapter provides a comparative analysis of these two models of performance evaluation, looking in particular at the level of the personnel of the courts and tribunals, and at the measurement of statistical results of their performance in the administration of justice. The comparison will open up the question as to whether measuring performances contributes to the improvement of the quality of justice. |
| format | Book chapter |
| id | oai:cris.upeu.edu.pe:20.500.15037/1609 |
| institution | UPeU |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2023 |
| publishDateRange | 2023 |
| publishDateSort | 2023 |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oai:cris.upeu.edu.pe:20.500.15037/16092026-10-30T16:16:15ZPerformance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A ComparisonBéjar, Luis JoséCasanovas, Juan AntonioVasquez Villanueva, Carlos AlbertoTribunalEconomic JusticePolitical scienceLawPower (physics)Public administrationPhysicsQuantum mechanicsSocial Sciences Economics, Econometrics and Finance Economics and Econometrics Law, Economics, and Judicial SystemsMexico, being a Federation, has different levels of jurisdictions, courts and tribunals; many differences exist between courts of different states and between state and federal courts. This chapter will focus in particular on the analysis of the performance models that regulate two of Mexico’s federal judicial bodies: on the one hand, the Judicial Power of the Federation, responsible for ordinary federal justice, but also playing a role as constitutional judge through the amparo trial; on the other hand, the Federal Tribunal of Administrative Justice, endowed with constitutional autonomy, and responsible for administrative litigation and for disciplinary sanctions against state employees. Both federal judicial bodies have in place a career system for civil servants and judges that also takes into account performance-based evaluation. Yet, the contents and effects of such evaluations are notably different in the two bodies. This is why the chapter provides a comparative analysis of these two models of performance evaluation, looking in particular at the level of the personnel of the courts and tribunals, and at the measurement of statistical results of their performance in the administration of justice. The comparison will open up the question as to whether measuring performances contributes to the improvement of the quality of justice.Book chapter10.1163/9789004680944_004https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.15037/1609W4386738417enComparative Legal Metrics978900468094497890046809372023-07-182026-06-13T14:16:27Z2026-06-13T14:16:27Z |
| spellingShingle | Tribunal Economic Justice Political science Law Power (physics) Public administration Physics Quantum mechanics Social Sciences Economics, Econometrics and Finance Economics and Econometrics Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems Béjar, Luis José Casanovas, Juan Antonio Vasquez Villanueva, Carlos Alberto Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title | Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title_full | Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title_fullStr | Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title_full_unstemmed | Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title_short | Performance-Based Evaluation in Mexico’s Federal Administrative Justice Tribunal and the Federal Judiciary Power: A Comparison |
| title_sort | performance based evaluation in mexico s federal administrative justice tribunal and the federal judiciary power a comparison |
| topic | Tribunal Economic Justice Political science Law Power (physics) Public administration Physics Quantum mechanics Social Sciences Economics, Econometrics and Finance Economics and Econometrics Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems |
| topic_facet | Tribunal Economic Justice Political science Law Power (physics) Public administration Physics Quantum mechanics Social Sciences Economics, Econometrics and Finance Economics and Econometrics Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems |
| url | https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.15037/1609 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT bejarluisjose performancebasedevaluationinmexicosfederaladministrativejusticetribunalandthefederaljudiciarypoweracomparison AT casanovasjuanantonio performancebasedevaluationinmexicosfederaladministrativejusticetribunalandthefederaljudiciarypoweracomparison AT vasquezvillanuevacarlosalberto performancebasedevaluationinmexicosfederaladministrativejusticetribunalandthefederaljudiciarypoweracomparison |